U.S. Gives Up Afghanistan's Korengal Valley To Taliban, Feeds the Taliban Ego and Puts Up An "Open For Business" Sign For Al Qaeda

Okay, I have NEVER been a fan of General McChrystal's new strategy in Afghanistan where he proposed and it was adopted that American and NATO troops would withdraw from remote locations and work more efficiently to guard the more populous areas like around the capital of Kabul and also Kandahar. But hey, I'm not military strategist...but it just seems to me that when you give the Taliban and subequently, al Qaeda, a sanctuary...you have opened yourself for NEVER getting rid of this enemy totally.

From the story at The Long War Journal:

The recent US withdrawal from the Korengal Valley in Kunar province in eastern Afghanistan has provided the Taliban with yet another "Taliban propaganda coup," as a video released shows enemy fighters in charge of the former US outposts.

In the video, the Taliban claim to have taken control of the Korengal Valley, while conducting a guided tour of an abandoned US outpost with an Al Jazeera reporter. Taliban fighters are seen walking through the base, which just days ago was occupied by US forces until they withdrew to comply with "the requirements of the new population-centric counterinsurgency strategy," according to Lieutenant General David Rodriguez, ISAF's Joint Command commander.

The Taliban are seen walking through the rows of intact HESCO barriers, the makeshift wire and mesh walls filled with earth that surround the outpost. US forces appeared to have left hastily, abandoning equipment and leaving fighting positions intact, with air conditioning units, unused HESCOs, razor wire, fuel jerry cans, furniture, and other items in full view.

The Taliban claimed that US forces left behind boxes of ammunition and plenty of fuel. The video shows ammunition boxes but it is not clear if the boxes are full or empty.

"There is a lot of ammunition left behind – mortars, rockets, and missiles," a local Taliban commander named Anwar told Al Jazeera. "This, God willing, we will [use] against them."

I want to point out two examples of why I don't like this new strategy.

First, let's look at what happened in Pakistan. The Pakistani government decided to allow the Taliban to set up shop in quite a few of the Northwest Provinces, hoping that the Taliban would just kick back and relax. The Taliban didn't. That territory they held wasn't enough - they pushed outward and southward - and they terrorized the agencies and provinces they were in and quite frankly, they struck with devastating terror attacks as far away as the capital of Islamabad. What the Pakistanis found out is that if you let the Taliban (and al Qaeda) have an inch of ground in your country, it's like a small group of cancer cells in one lymph node - if you leave them be, they spread quickly throughout the body, eventually killing it.

Second, let's look at what happened in Iraq. General Petraeus' amazing "Surge" strategy was based on NOT sitting inside of Baghdad and waiting for al Qaeda in Iraq attacks but moving troops OUT towards the enemy, cutting off his suicide mission routes and also patrolling the safe havens where planning was done and IED's were produced.

Can you imagine the strategic planning that will be done by the Taliban and al Qaeda in the Korengal Valley now? Can you imagine the number of land mines and IED's that will be produced in that safe haven now and then transported throughout Afghanistan?

I realize that Afghanistan is not Iraq - it's a vast country with terrain that simply doesn't allow a U.S. or NATO presence everywhere but at the same time, I'm totally against giving the enemy ANY kind of symbolic victory and I'm sure as hell not happy about a withdrawl from an area as close to the city of Kabul as it is (look at map above).

US withdrawal from Korengal Valley a 'Taliban propaganda coup'


The recent US withdrawal from the Korengal Valley in Kunar province in eastern Afghanistan has provided the Taliban with yet another "Taliban propaganda coup," as a video released shows enemy fighters in charge of the former US outposts.

In the video, the Taliban claim to have taken control of the Korengal Valley, while conducting a guided tour of an abandoned US outpost with an Al Jazeera reporter. Taliban fighters are seen walking through the base, which just days ago was occupied by US forces until they withdrew to comply with "the requirements of the new population-centric counterinsurgency strategy," according to Lieutenant General David Rodriguez, ISAF's Joint Command commander.

The Taliban are seen walking through the rows of intact HESCO barriers, the makeshift wire and mesh walls filled with earth that surround the outpost. US forces appeared to have left hastily, abandoning equipment and leaving fighting positions intact, with air conditioning units, unused HESCOs, razor wire, fuel jerry cans, furniture, and other items in full view.

The Taliban claimed that US forces left behind boxes of ammunition and plenty of fuel. The video shows ammunition boxes but it is not clear if the boxes are full or empty.

"There is a lot of ammunition left behind – mortars, rockets, and missiles," a local Taliban commander named Anwar told Al Jazeera. "This, God willing, we will [use] against them."

The US military said the fuel was left behind for civilians to use, and claimed fighting positions were destroyed and munitions were removed.

The Taliban are now claiming to be in full control of the Korengal Valley and admitted that "a number of Arab fighters have moved into the area," the term used for al Qaeda.

US move feeds the Taiban propaganda mill

Late last year, the Taliban produced a similar video and made similar claims after US forces withdrew from isolated combat outposts in the neighboring province of Nuristan. The Taliban were seen ranging through a combat outpost in the remote district of Kamdesh that just days before had been nearly overrun during an enemy assault. Within a month after the US withdrawal, the Taliban began openly governing in Kamdesh.

While the US pullback from the remote outposts in Kunar and Nuristan in eastern Afghanistan may make sense from a tactical perspective, the moves are serving to embolden the Taliban and hurt the Coalition's strategic message, several senior US military officers who wish to remain anonymous due to the controversy over this issue told The Long War Journal.

"There is truth that these outposts are hard to defend and are tough on resources, tough to resuppply," A senior military officer said. "And the return in terms of counterinsurgency success may be low, as we're not winning many people over. But look at what we have signaled to the Afghan people: we will leave you if it becomes too difficult."

"We are giving the Taliban propaganda on a silver platter," another officer said. "Note how Al Jazeera was on tap for this pullout. We can dismiss this all we want, but the reality is this is another Taliban propaganda coup. The message may be lost on those in ISAF but it isn't lost on the Afghan people, many whom already think we have one foot out the door."

“We tell ourselves much of this battle is a battle for perceptions, yet we often refuse to manage those perceptions,” the officer continued. “We are having it handed to us when it comes to the information war, it is that simple.”

Another officer said the withdrawals from Nuristan and Kunar can hinder efforts to sell an operation to Afghans in Kandahar.

"We're going to them to tell them we're here to protect them, but they can see we haven't kept our promises in the east," the officer said. "And then we wonder why they sit on the fence."